Search Mediators Near You:

Cognitive Bias Revisited

From Michael Carbone’s listserv

By now we should all be familiar with what “cognitive bias” is. 
It’s a mistake in reasoning or decision-making that is caused by sticking to our own pre-conceived ideas based upon personal preferences or feelings.
But now comes an article by Brian Costa in the May 13, 2017 issue of the Wall Street Journal under the headline “Why Golfers Overestimate Their Ability.” In it he writes that “New data suggests that most players think they will hit the ball farther than they do…It reveals a persistent-and tough to overcome-cognitive bias that causes most players to regularly choose the wrong club…. They think that they will hit the ball farther than they actually do because they tend to remember and make decisions based upon their best shots in the past while forgetting about the rest of them.”
Mr. Costa goes on to write about a 1999 study which found that “people tend to hold overly favorable views of their abilities in a wide range of social and intellectual disciplines.” And in support of that conclusion he cites a 1992 study which found that “engineers at two Silicon Valley software firms were asked how they ranked relative to their co-workers. Forty two percent of engineers at one firm and 32% of engineers at the other firm rated themselves in the top 5% of performers.” So here we have professionals who should be very good at math reaching a conclusion that is mathematically impossible to support. 
The next time that you are tempted to evaluate a case based solely upon good results in similar cases that you settled, think twice. Or if you are tempted to indulge in probabilities such as “I have a seventy-five percent chance of winning,” think about whether you have any data to support your conclusion. If not, are you engaging in guesswork?  Are you pulling a number out of the air? And most importantly, will your client buy it?   




Michael P. Carbone

MICHAEL P. CARBONE is a senior mediator who has also served as an arbitrator and court-appointed referee. His dispute resolution practice has been built over a period of more than 25 years and covers a wide range of fields.   His exceptional combination of transactional and litigation experience enables him to handle complex litigation… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Guidelines For Using Collaborative Agreement-Seeking Processes

This article originally appeared in the April 1997 issue of Consensus, a newspaper published jointly by the Consensus Building Institute and the MIT-Harvard Public Disputes Program. Special Excerpt The following...

By Managing Editor

A Mediator’s Backpack

Generation Why Blog by Aik KramerI stumbled upon this great thread on lifehacker: What’s in your awesome backpacks? Working as a mediator/researcher I basically live in my backpack and use...

By Aik Kramer

Co-Parenting Tips During a Divorce

Divorce is often a period fraught with emotions and uncertainties. While divorce is difficult for anyone involved, parents bear a special burden. Divorcing parents face the tremendous challenge of having...

By Mitch Cohen

Find a Mediator