Find Mediators Near You:

Cognitive Surplus” And Participation In Government

From John Folk-Williams’s blog Cross Collaborate

Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this video.

Some Rights Reserved by Web2Expo at

Clay Shirky, author of Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing Without Organizations Cognitive Surplus and Participation in Government, presented his idea of cognitive surplus a couple of years ago, but it seems especially relevant to the current push toward open government, most notably by the Obama Administration but also by public agencies at all levels. Like other interpreters of internet technology, he describes the impact of new platforms for participation primarily on business, media and popular culture rather than government and public policy. His idea of cognitive surplus, though, as a source of public inventiveness and action that applies to every sector, public or private.

Several ideas in the video readily translate from mass media to the context of government:

  • The public is learning to convert at least a small amount of time spent passively watching TV to participatory action in online networks. This started with hobbies and social interaction – collaborative networks of gamers, photo sharing groups on Flickr, reunion of friends on Facebook – but now extends to political campaigns and crowdsourcing ideas for business and government.

  • For decades, media [government] has regarded the public as consumers of information rather than participants. The growing demand, especially from younger people who have grown up with the internet, is for an interactive experience where the viewer adds value as a producer of content. Media [government] needs to adapt to a cultural shift toward participation and collaboration.

  • Information, as well as media content, is most often controlled exclusively by institutions and businesses. Shirky cites a Brazilian professor who created a crime map of the country. He found it easier to develop the data from scratch rather than attempt to get it from the public authorities, so great were their barriers to disclosure. This example points exactly to the purpose of the transparency dimension of the Open Government Initiative: to publish online the data that the private sector can put into useful forms with existing online tools. (In this case, Google Maps.)

  • The early phase of the shift to producing as well as consuming comes with a lot of chaos and failed attempts as one experiment after another is tried. The period of greatest productivity from the untapped potential of people’s “spare time” is likely to come after the novelty has worn off and new tools have become as standard as the telephone.

Shirky argues that this shift to participating and producing is not a fad dependent on one technology but a lasting change in society. I think this is true and especially relevant to the open government movement. Because of new public expectations and resources, it will be hard for any government not to collaborate with its citizens.


John Folk-Williams

I’m John Folk-Williams, the publisher and editor of Cross Collaborate. Since the early 1980s, I’ve been a practitioner and writer in the field of public policy collaboration, interest-based negotiation, mediation and the involvement of citizens in the decisions that affect their lives. A site like this is itself a collaboration… MORE >

Featured Members

View all

Read these next


A Dark Day in America: Torture Veto Vetoed

Being "neutral" does not mean we check our common human decency at the door. Do understand this however.  When we are feeling frightened and disoriented, anger and its explosive cousin...

By Victoria Pynchon

English Professors Do It — Negotiate that Is

The google algorithm throws these random musings on negotiation up to me on a weekly basis because "negotiate" is one of my "google alerts."  (have I said god bless google...

By Victoria Pynchon

A Lot of Common Sense and a Little Mazel Can Go a Long Way

Recently I mediated a contract dispute between a health care provider and an insurer. The main issue concerned billing practices for claims submitted. The plaintiffs alleged that claims were underpaid...

By Nancy Shuger