From Colin Rule’s blog NovoJustice
“What I hadn’t realized was that Craigslist had actually filed a bunch of similar, equally questionable, lawsuits against others. One of those others is a guy named Paul Hubert, who wrote some software that made it easier to manage your Craigslist postings. We’ve been in touch with Mr. Hubert… who did not find out that he was being sued at all, until months after the court already ruled in a default judgment against him. Default judgments happen when someone doesn’t respond, but if you’re never informed of the lawsuit, it’s pretty difficult to respond at all. Hubert insists that he was never served, and the first he heard of the lawsuit was a couple months after the default judgment (for over $1.2 million) when someone tried to collect it from him.
Hubert makes it clear that his software was designed for legitimate uses of Craigslist, for those who needed better management tools. In fact, he makes it clear that he left out and/or disabled certain features if he realized they might be attractive to spammers. For example, after noticing that the Craigslist Personals section was hit with a lot of spam, and realizing that such a category probably wouldn’t need such a management system, he blocked the software from posting to that category. Hubert claims that in 2007 Craig Newmark himself reached out to Hubert to ask for some details about the software. Hubert says that the emails were "encouraging" and never once did Newmark suggest any concerns or problems with the software, let alone ask Hubert to stop offering it. Hubert also notes that after running into more issues with spammers trying to use his software, he shut down the whole thing at the end of 2008.
Hubert, who is unemployed, is reasonably perplexed and upset about the whole thing. He never knew about the lawsuit, was never asked to stop offering his software (which he did anyway), and is now being told he has to pay $1.2 million which he doesn’t have. He claims that the lawyer trying to collect the money has told him that Craigslist wants to "make an example" of him.
I’m greatly troubled by Craigslist’s actions here.”
The following Keynote Address was delivered by Bennett G. Picker at a conference in Florence, Italy organized by the newly launched Florence International Mediation Chamber and the International Mediation Institute....
By Bennett G. PickerIn this episode of the ICODR podcast, Ian interviews Professor Orna Rabinovich-Einy of the Faculty of Law at the University of Haifa. Her areas of expertise are alternative dispute resolution...
By Orna Rabinovich-Einy, Ian MacDuffWhat if we calculated the amount of time, energy, and resources wasted on unresolved conflicts in the workplace? We would need to include in our accounting productivity losses due to...
By Rian Thomas