Delivering Bad News In Negotiation: How Big Is Your Conference Room?

From John DeGroote’s Settlement Perspectives

The conference table had 40 chairs, and my client’s team filled almost half of them.  We had been asked to show up with the folks needed to get a deal done, and the backchannel weekend chatter had all been positive.  As the meeting began, our optimism crashed as the other side went on the attack, denying my client’s most important request and questioning why it had ever been included.

People usually need to hear the truth whether it’s convenient or not, but there’s more than one one way to convey a difficult message.  How often have you seen someone delight in dropping bad news onto the conference table as the meeting begins?  The adrenaline rush might satisfy some, but does this approach do any good?

Thank You for Your Interest

The lawyer who delivered the bad news to my team that day prided himself in his aggressive persona, and his performance was true to his reputation.  Unfortunately his glee was short-lived; my team and I worked night and day to avoid a deal with him, and we succeeded.  I wonder if he’ll ever realize what a disservice he did his client.

Public Praise, Private Reprimand

Negotiation is tough, and bad news is inevitable.  Sometimes the answer is “no,” the facts aren’t always convenient, and any deal to be reached has to account for it all.  But think before you fire back with uncomfortable facts — as Nancy Hudgins has explained in posts here and here, bullying gets no one closer to closure.  As you respond to the other side, you may want to keep the words of Vince Lombardi in mind:

Praise in public; criticize in private.

Lombardi’s advice might not have been directed at negotiators, but his approach works here — I’ll modify his message to say that a small group is usually a better audience for bad news.  “Success has many fathers, while failure is an orphan” is a proverb for a reason — people want to be associated with success, and they don’t want to be tied to failure.  At the moment you deliver bad news — whether you reject the other side’s offer or reveal evidence that undermines their position — a large group across the table will become more defensive than productive.

So Who Needs to Be in the Room?

Other than your need to have people with dealmaking authority in the room, why do you care who the other side plans to bring to a settlement meeting, a mediation, or a deal negotiation?  You don’t have to subscribe to the butterfly effect to realize that every person at the table impacts the negotiation in some way — I have watched individual plaintiffs overreact to bad news because their spouses are present, I have seen lawyers bristle at minor inconvenient facts in front of their clients, and I even noticed one witness unable to deal with bad facts when an attractive law clerk appeared at his deposition.  Think about that as you demand the other side bring a second insurance adjuster, two more folks from the home office, and the CEO to the mediation.

Are there occasions where a big group needs to hear bad news?  Absolutely, but almost never when a deal needs to get done quickly.  Think of first grade:  When Miss Haskins wanted to tell you how bad your handwriting was, did she reveal your Big Chief tablet to the entire class, or did she chat with you about your (terrible) penmanship when no one was around?

The next time you have bad news to reveal, get a smaller conference room.  You’ll be glad you did.


John DeGroote

John serves as a mediator and arbitrator in complex business, technology, and intellectual property matters involving parties and interests around the country and beyond — often before litigation is filed. Prior to his service as a mediator and arbitrator, John served as the lead settlement negotiator in hundreds of cases,… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


The Key to a Successful Mediation Practice is ‘Being in the Circle’

A common complaint that resonates in our field is lack of paying cases. There are more opportunities than ever to volunteer as a mediator. However, transitioning from volunteer to paid...

By Troy Morgan

AudioBlog: Animal Conflicts and Alternative Dispute Resolution

Texas Conflict Coach Audio Blog by Pattie PorterDuring our series, esteemed leaders in law and dispute resolution Ms. Debra Hamilton of New York and Mr. Gary Norman of Maryland will...

By Patricia Porter

What’s Your Approach? Process v. Subject

From Clare Fowler's Fairly Legal Blog When I first began mediating, my mentor told me that a good mediator can mediate any type of case. The important thing was not...

By Clare Fowler

Find a Mediator