Find Mediators Near You:

Girardi Troubled by 25-Year Old Confidentiality Agreement in Priest Molestation Case

The subject of private judging and maintaining confidentiality in settlement agreements was in the news again today, this time in the Los Angeles Times article “Prying into Judicial Secrecy.”

The article announces a significant new study by UCLA Law School and the Rand Corporation on the effect of private judging and confidential settlement agreements on the civil justice system.

But what really caught my attention was Tom Girardi’s reported comment that he was “troubled” by a confidentiality agreement he signed 25 years ago on behalf of a boy who alleged he was molested by a Catholic priest.  As the Times reported:

Girardi said he had doubts about [his] client’s claims at the time [but that] when the massive pedophilia scandal in the Catholic Church came to public light, [he] said he learned that the priest had molested 17 kids. 

“My confidentiality agreement probably had negative consequences” for all of these kids, Girardi acknowledged.

Both of these candid statements are both necessary and courageous.  They demonstrate that even the best of us sometimes doubt our own clients’ claims and that we might sometimes inadvertently harm others while doing the job we’re ethically obliged to do — “zealously representing” our clients.

The last time I saw Tom was during the Vioxx trial Judge Chaney’s courtroom.  I’d brought my dad down to court — now 83 and failing physically and mentally.  At the break, Girardi stopped by to shake Dad’s hand and say a few generous things about his tenure as Commissioner in the downtown Superior Court.  I’ll never forget this kindness, particularly the memory of the tears that coursed down Dad’s face to have someone of Girardi’s reputation call him “Your Honor” again.

Thanks Tom.


Victoria Pynchon

Attorney-mediator Victoria Pynchon is a panelist with ADR Services, Inc. Ms. Pynchon was awarded her LL.M Degree in Dispute Resolution from the Straus Institute in May of 2006, after 25 years of complex commercial litigation practice, with sub-specialties in intellectual property, securities fraud, antitrust, insurance coverage, consumer class actions and all… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Resolving Strategy and Structure Conflicts

Perhaps two of the most challenging conflicts confronting organizations today concern (1) formulating strategy and then (2) manifesting it throughout the organization’s lines of business, departments, work groups, and jobs....

By Ralph Kilmann

To Be Effective, Mediators Should Learn to be More . . . Stupid?

 CMP Resolutions Blog by Katherine Graham Much of current mediation training is consciously ‘additive’, in that it puts forward various  frameworks, theories and models. This article argues, only partially tongue-in-cheek, that...

By Michael Jacobs

Evidence in a Small Claims Court Mediation

From the Small Claims Courts blog of Leo Hura.In a multi-hour mediation session my co-mediator reminded me “we are not fact finders” reflected by his refusal to look at documents...

By Leo Hura