Mediating Amidst a Crisis: Is Online Mediation a Solution for India?

Originally published by ELS Review, https://elsreview.wordpress.com/ in March, 2020.

With COVID-19 being declared a pandemic by the WHO, the day-to-day affairs of a common man’s life have come to a standstill with the enforcement of multiple lockdowns to combat the outbreak. In India, workplaces and courts, being non-essential to public health and sanitation have been ordered to shut operations temporarily. However, due to rapid advancements in technology, “work from home” has been made a reality, enabling firms to continue operations remotely while giving employees the benefit of not having to be physically present at office amidst this lockdown.

Dispute resolution mechanisms in India on the other hand, have not kept up with time and technology. With the absence of any dispute resolution mechanism to run parallel to such normalcy in life and work culture, one can forecast the accrual of an enormous number of new cases being filed in addition to the already pending massive backlog of cases that commercial courts must deal with subsequent to them resuming operations. An additional overburdening of the already burdened courts is going to result in further delay in the delivery of justice.

This, however, is not the case globally. Most countries have successfully identified and implemented online dispute resolution mechanisms that have been able to sustain their functionality even during a crisis. Online dispute resolution bridges the gap and increases access to those individuals who, due to various reasons such as, inconvenience travelling to a common venue, paucity of time/resources, and reservations in meeting the other party physically among other reasons are unable to have any recourse to resolution of disputes. In the light of the present COVID-19 outbreak and social distancing measures, firms present abroad continue to offer their services at discounted rates, to provide to the public, access to dispute resolution from the safety and comfort of their homes.

Mediation as a dispute resolution mechanism is now globally recognized. It has also been gaining increasing acceptance and recognition in India, especially after the amendment to the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 mandating pre-litigation mediation for non-urgent cases. The authors, by way of this post, taking inspiration from global models, seek to explore the viability of implementing a model of online dispute resolution, more specifically, online mediation in India that would serve the purpose of sustaining its functionality at all times alike.

Process of Online Mediation

There are a number of firms that provide Online Mediation services in a number of common and civil law countries abroad. Service providers abroad, cater to parties looking to resolve primarily, familial or commercial disputes. Most service providers follow a standard model of mediation practice for individuals who wish to resolve their disputes remotely.

Initiating the process of online mediation once both parties agree to mediate is fairly simple. Interested individuals are required to visit the website of a service provider of their choice and self-register. As general practice, this process of registration is quick, user friendly and typically only requires an individual’s credentials and a factual summary of the dispute, which may include questions about the parties, the sum involved and/or about previous settlements. Post registration, individuals are contacted by the service provider to discuss technicalities like the fee, date and time of the mediation session. Often, websites of service providers also offer free downloadable guides to interested individuals regarding the modalities of the online mediation session.

Service providers catering to the resolution of family disputes have a fairly simple modus operandi. Typically, they require both parties to have access to a stable Internet connection, a device (preferably a computer) with a camera and a microphone, and subscription to videoconference applications like zoom or Skype in order to avail the service.

Service providers catering to the resolution of commercial disputes however, usually provide their own applications for the conduction of the mediation session. Such applications are usually videoconferencing platforms offering high standards of privacy and security to facilitate the exchange of confidential data between parties during mediation sessions. Basic requirements like a stable Internet connection and device follow.

The process of online mediation is completely party driven, just as in the case of traditional mediations. The individuals involved make decisions regarding the duration and nature of the sessions and have the freedom to opt to have their lawyers or other interested parties of their choice by their sides. Upon the completion of said registration and fulfillment of requirements of the process, the online mediation session is typically a three-way videoconference between the parties and an expert online mediator, who is appointed by the service provider. It is ensured by the service provider that the mediator so appointed, is a qualified neutral third party with no prior association with the individuals involved in the dispute.

Implementing Online Mediation in India:

Mediation, has been steadily gaining recognition and acceptance from across India, with most familial and civil disputes now being referred to mediation by courts coupled with mandated pre-litigation mediation for commercial matters. With the increased usage and awareness about mediation as a dispute resolution mechanism, one is likely to assume that the implementation of the global model of online mediation in India should be fairly simple. This however, isn’t the case by virtue of potential barriers to the implementation of online mediation in India such as; lack of legal recognition to settlements arrived at mediation proceedings, poor Internet infrastructure and a general lack of awareness and faith among the public regarding mediation as a dispute resolution mechanism.

The very foundation of online mediation proceedings is highly reliant on clear legal provisions being made in favour of both the enforceability and acceptance of traditional and online mediation settlements alike. At present, individuals seeking to accord mediation settlements a sanction under law prefer to have it recorded as consent decrees or awards before courts or tribunals. This is not only contrary to the very purpose of mediation reducing the burden of courts but also takes away the true essence of online mediations being “online”. Furthermore, a strong and steady Internet connection is the primary requirement for the conduction of uninterrupted online mediation sessions. With India falling short on both Internet speed and geographical coverage, this barrier may be antithetical to the promise of ease and comfort that online mediation otherwise offers. Finally, a general lack of awareness among the public regarding mediation as an effective and efficient mode of dispute resolution is likely to discourage the establishment of online mediation service providers in India owing to the potential lack of users of such online services.

However, while these barriers may seem discouraging to the future of online mediation in India, it is pertinent to note that in the recent years, India has seen a phenomenal rise in the number of mediation institutions training and sensitizing individuals regarding the benefits and importance of mediation being chosen as the preferred mode of dispute resolution. While mediation institutes during their awareness workshops focus on traditional mediations, a simple inclusion of online mediations as another viable alternative would suffice to increase awareness. Further, with India having become a signatory to The United Nations Convention on International Settlement Agreements Resulting from Mediation (“Singapore Mediation Convention”) on August 1, 2019, it is expected that India will soon roll out new legislations recognising both cross border and local mediation settlements alike to ensure effective implementation of the convention. Lastly, to circumvent the issue of poor Internet infrastructure, it is suggested that service providers offer high-speed Internet dongles to parties to facilitate uninterrupted mediation sessions.

Conclusions:

The lockdown due to the COVID-19 Pandemic has shown us that a lot of the things that we imagined only doing offline can be done online as well. The future of Online Mediation in India is a bright one because of various reasons. The first reason being, our country just recently became a signatory to the Singapore Mediation Convention. With the present Government in India promoting online modes of everything from payment to documentation, it is only a matter of time that an online mode of Mediation is put in place as well. Secondly, the fact that various communities in India have had multiple methods of resolving disputes outside courts since time immemorial just goes to show that mediation and its online counterpart will fly well with the citizens of the country. Lastly, the very benefits of Online Mediation make it a very attractive process. Low costs, the convenience of not having to be physically present at a certain venue, and quick and swift resolution of disputes only add to its feasibility and appeal to the people.

                       

Kartikeya Singh

Kartikeya Singh is a III Year Student, B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) at National Law University Jodhpur. MORE >

                       

Sandhya Swaminathan

Sandhya Swaminathan is a III Year Student, B.B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) at National Law University Jodhpur. MORE >