Search Mediators Near You:

Negotiation Mistake 3: Ignoring Emotions (The Elephant In The Room)

From the blog of Nancy Hudgins

(This is the third in a series of 7 Mistakes Really Good Negotiators Make.)

If you think I’m talking about clients’ emotions you’d be half right. Let’s start with you.

Emotions are often sparked in lawyers who are negotiating for their clients. How many times have you been frustrated when the other side hasn’t moved as much as you expected, especially when you just made an impressive move? How many times have you angrily reacted when it becomes apparent that the other side has not evaluated the case as realistically as you have? How many times have you entertained the irritating/anxious thought that a case you really wanted to settle is not going to settle?

Neuroscientists tell us that when we feel threatened, our lower reptilian brain (the amygdala) reacts first: fight, flight or flee. It takes some time for this emotional flooding to subside before we are able to access the higher, more rational, parts of our brain.

We can train ourselves to lessen the impact of emotions in mediations. Here are some skills to combat emotional reactivity in negotiation:

1. Preparation. Strong negative emotions come up in almost every mediation. Prepare for them by reminding yourself ahead of time that you are likely to experience them and have strategies in mind to deal with them.

2. Pay attention during the mediation. The sooner you notice negative emotions arising, the less sway they may have.

3. Name them. Oh, I’m beginning to feel frustrated because the negotiation is not going the way I had anticipated….

4. Take a couple of deep breaths—give the emotion time to dissipate.

5. Try to be a fly on the wall, looking at the tableau, as opposed to being in the thick of it.

6. Take a break if you need it. Get up and walk around. Even around the block, if necessary.

Now you’re ready to begin anew, able to access the brilliant strategies that make you the successful negotiator that you are.

Use these strategies to help your clients, too. Prepare them for the emotional roller coaster. Pay attention to their emotional states during the mediation. Help them work through them rather than ignoring them. They’ll be better decision makers, too.


Nancy Hudgins

Nancy Hudgins, a San Francisco mediator and lawyer, began specializing in civil litigation in the 1970's. She has represented both plaintiffs and defendants, chiefly in personal injury, medical malpractice, elder abuse and product liability lawsuits, but also in a wide variety of complex litigation, including civil rights, fraud and class… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Zealous Advocacy Can Kill

His divorce was going really badly: aggressive lawyers on both sides, court battles and blame-ridden affidavits! About a month ago, he was supposed to call me to see if there...

By Laura Tarcea

3 Oft-Forgotten Questions to Ask Yourself Before Family Mediation

On top of the questions to ask your mediator, there are some things you should ask yourself before mediation to make sure you've thought through all possible parenting issues that...

By Ben Coltrin

Tips for Dealing with Emotion in Mediation

Emotional Literacy For Mediators 1. Begin thinking about the emotional climate of a case early on, preferably during the pre-mediation phase. Sometimes it will be apparent. If not, inquire of...

By Eileen Barker

Find a Mediator