Find Mediators Near You:

Not My Job… Unless…

By the time I reach the end of this article, some reader will have already begun typing a response. To save everyone time, let me qualify by acknowledging there are many well-founded opinions about this topic. This article only represents my observations and preference.

To a case, every time the disputants have agreed upon settlement terms, no matter how many times we recite them together, when the final agreement is drafted by the attorneys negotiations begin again over what some may consider to be minor details thus extending the dispute for additional days or weeks. One of my professors in law school made it point that lawyers often see their job as being obstacles to negotiated agreements by insisting upon terms that favor one’s own client above all others. Perhaps the point is a little extreme, but not altogether inaccurate.

I recall a mediation I conducted a while ago in which, at the end of the substantive negotiations, we continued to haggle over the use of ONE word for over an hour. In my view, the word at issue was adequately benign that it burdened no one. Nonetheless, counsel were insistent. I am observing negotiations between counsel over language in an agreement settling a very routine money settlement. The matter has been settled in substance for many weeks and payment is being delayed because lawyers want to have their way when it comes to agreement language. I watch the discussion and, frankly, am nonplussed. Because of this tendency in my lawyer colleagues, long ago I made a decision to maintain management of my mediations and from my position as a neutral, I employ a standard settlement agreement that includes all the usual terms and conditions while adding only the background detail and substantive terms. Even with this approach, the final efforts at settlement often take as long as the negotiations.

I have found that, most of the time, this approach saves a substantial amount of time and expense for the parties and since a mediator should be familiar with the law on interpretation, structure and language of a mediated agreement, I have found agreements that have been drafted primarily by a trained mediator, to be less vague and far more complete (and consequently, enforceable) than those drafted during or after the mediation by counsel. I do not mean to say that I, or any mediator, is any smarter than counsel. Rather, just as attorneys are acutely aware of the nuances of their legal specialties, so are most mediators when it comes to the language and form of a solid agreement. I have also seen mediated agreements apparently drafted by mediators that are incomprehensible messes that would be difficult for many judges to enforce.

At bottom, the mediated case belongs to the disputants. I perceive my duty as being to them and to do the best job of resolving the dispute with a meaningful, satisfactory and enforceable written settlement agreement signed by all parties. If counsel wish to proceed on their own, I step aside.

author

Don Cripe

Donald Cripe is a Law Professor (Mediation/ADR), Univ. of La Verne College of Law; Superior Court Judicial Arbitrator since 1996—having conducted several hundred arbitrations; Settlement Judge since 1996; Family Law Mediator-Riverside Superior Court Mandatory Dispute Resolution Conference Program; General Mediator-Dispute Resolution Services, Riverside; Civil Mediator- Riverside County Superior Court; Riverside… MORE

Featured Members

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

New Jersey Family Mediation Gets A Boost

From the blog Mediation Marketing TipsAs reported in the latest issue of NJAPM’s quarterly newsletter, “Family Law Attorneys Must Tell Clients About CDR” by William H. Donahue, Jr., Esq., the...

By Managing Editor
Category

Hugh McIssac: Child Custody Mediation – Video

Hugh McIssac shares an example of a child custody mediation he had early on. He notes that the positive outcome that resulted would never have occurred if it had been...

By Hugh McIssac
Category

The Link Between Weather and War

A recent study conducted by the Earth Institute at Columbia University tells a startling story. Climate change data gathered from 1950 to 2004 on the naturally occurring patterns of El...

By Christine Tsai
×