From the Blog of Phyllis G. Pollack.
According to psychologist Albert Mehrabian, more than fifty (50) percent of the total meaning of a spoken message comes through facial expressions and other non-verbal communication. One such non-verbal cue is pride.
In a June 25, 2007 article in the Los Angeles Times entitled “Proud of yourself? Everyone can tell,” Janet Cromley, notes that according to recent research, “. . . pride appears to be a universal, human emotion, and it comes in two flavors: positive and arrogant.” (Id.)
According to researchers Jessica Tracy an assistant professor of psychology at the University of British Columbia, and Richard Robins, a UC Davis psychology professor:
“. . . pride is a cross-cultural phenomenon. . . and that humans recognize two distinct types of pride: justifiable pride and arrogant, or conceited pride.”
“. . . people who feel justifiable are likely to be more extroverted and conscientious, whereas those who feel conceited pride tend to be narcissistic and attribute their success to their innate abilities rather than their personal efforts.”
How does pride relate to a mediation? It can trigger a reality check. If a party displays “pride” during a mediation, take a moment to determine if it is “positive” or “authentic” pride related solely to the accomplishment at issue or “negative” pride caused solely by arrogance or conceit. Once you determine the source of the “pride”, you can formulate the appropriate response to this non-verbal communication which may or may not include a dose of reality (depending upon the reason for the “pride”).
In conclusion, while non-verbal communication is always important, it is particularly so in mediation. Pay attention to these cues, and if “pride” is the cue, determine its source in order to figure out your next move.
. . . Just something to think about.
William Hartgering describes early talks of pushing to institutionalize mediation and the influence of Getting to Yes, by Fisher and Ury.By William E. Hartgering
Kluwer Mediation BlogIn this article, I discuss some of the perception and cognitive biases relevant to conflict as well as the interaction between biases and conflict. I think that it...By Catherine Brys