Had my first personal experience last week–after over three hundred mediations–at being accused of being biased, a mental aberration mediators avoid like the plague (even ahead of avoiding tired cliches). The perception of bias appeared to be based on my comments regarding problems I saw in the perceiver’s case. Now, folks, if a mediator standing outside the forest can’t share with you what he or she sees as a weakness in your case that you may not see because you’re standing amongst all those tall pines, you are not taking advantage of the mediator’s services.
Okay, the mediator may be dead wrong. Not unusual for someone who probably is hearing the facts of your case for the first time. If the observation is a valid one, it’s time to reevaluate your negotiating position. If it’s not on all fours, ignore it–or, better, persuasively rebut it. If it just ticks you off, you had better look deep inside yourself and determine why it disturbs you so much.
Remember, the mediator will be doing the same thing with the other side, and, often, confidentiality in the caucus prevents him or her from disclosing what he has said or has been said to him. Also, the mediator does not suffer the gladiatorial enthusiasm “enjoyed” by the litigators. He or she frequently sees things the lawyers have shoved out of their consciousnesses in order better to prepare for battle. The battle, of course, is the trial, the last resort in our judicial system from which mediation is committed to do its level best to save the parties.
A footnote to all this. Mediators recognize when they are being had. They have to be on their toes, when accused of bias (hopefully a rare occasion), to avoid demonstrating their lack of it by reversing the perceived bias. When I was in general practice, nothing made me more nervous than having a “friendly judge” on my case. I always believed, if he was my friend, he had to be honest, and, if he was honest, he might unconsciously bend over backwards not to show a bias in my favor. I don’t have to tell you what that could have resulted in.
From the Disputing Blog of Karl Bayer, Victoria VanBuren, and Holly Hayes. Our August post on the “bad faith” mediation section of Texas House Bill 2256 (read more about the...
By Holly HayesOne of the most rewarding cases I have settled during my decade as a mediator occurred last year. On paper, it involved a business litigation partnership dispute involving two married...
By Janet Rubin FieldsDispute Settlement Counsel by Michael Zeytoonian. Most people have a primary care physician. But people and small businesses don’t often have a primary care lawyer. This primary care lawyer that...
By Michael A. Zeytoonian
