The Eyes Have It

From the Blog of Phyllis G. Pollack.

       When you smile, do your eyes smile, too? If not, you’re faking it! According to a recent research study, “. . . the eyes might hold the clues for bogus versus genuine smiles.” (“Rejection Fosters Intuition” by Jeanna  Bryner,, October 17, 2008.)

      As Ms. Bryner notes,

      “ “A real smile is not shown in the mouth; it’s shown in the eyes”. . . “There are muscles around the eyes that are indicative of a real smile, whereas a fake smile just requires the mouth muscles.” ” (Id.)

       The article written by Ms. Bryner actually focuses on the thesis that rejection fosters intuition. “New research suggests [that] individuals who have faced the cold shoulder can more easily spot phony people.” (Id.)

        Based on a study of 32 participants, researcher Michael Bernstein, a doctoral student in social psychology at Miami University in Ohio, concluded that “those primed to feel rejection distinguished the fake smiles nearly 80 percent of the time, compared to 60 percent for the accepted and control individuals.”

       How do they do it? Mr. Bernstein opines that those individuals who have suffered rejection in their lives and thus are primed for it “…are probably looking harder at those faces…” and are probably focusing much more on the eyes to determine, if, they, too, are smiling.” (Id.) Hence, the smile is all in the eyes. 

       Experts in negotiation agree that non-verbal communication or body language conveys much more and is much more telling than the actual words spoken or even the way the words are said. In fact, psychologist Albert Mehrabian opines that approximately 55% of the total meaning of a spoken message comes from facial expressions and other non-verbal communication, while 7% comes from the meaning of the spoken word and 38% comes from the way we say the words.

       Thus, good negotiators focus on the non-verbal cues or body language to determine if the speaker is sincere. This latest study confirms the importance of non-verbal communication: the eyes of a person will tell you a lot. . . is she sincere or faking it?

       In your next negotiation or mediation, look at the other person’s eyes; focus on them and read them. They may very well tell you what is really going on behind that facial expression – including whether the smile is real or fake!

       . . . Just something to think about.


Phyllis Pollack

Phyllis Pollack with PGP Mediation uses a facilitative, interest-based approach. Her preferred mediation style is facilitative in the belief that the best and most durable resolutions are those achieved by the parties themselves. The parties generally know the business issues and priorities, personalities and obstacles to a successful resolution as… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Settle It Never? More on Stringfellow

These are the cases that made me name my mediation business "Settle It Now." The contamination of groundwater here in Southern California as the result of discharges from the  Stringfellow...

By Victoria Pynchon

Slow Down and Be the Bedouin

It feels productive to toss out ideas for a solution and demonstrate how much we want to help. But it’s usually unproductive if we haven’t done something essential first: Make...

By Tammy Lenski

Uncertainty by @jonathanfields

I read an interesting book lately called Uncertainty by Jonathan Fields recently and it has changed the way I think about many things. The tagline for this book say “Turning...

By Jason Dykstra

Find a Mediator