This PDF is a case study of an “outside mediation boundaries” project in Oregon, the 2.7 million acre Western Oregon Plan Revisions. This graphic-rich report is less a “we did this, and then we did that” than a reflection on what happens when one tries to design approaches that will be more empowering than traditional outreach yet can include more people than traditional public policy mediation.
Section I. Introduction
Section II. Ethics of Web Design Analyzes what is gained and lost outside the mediation crucible, the challenges and practical benefits of creating a neutral web forum absent such a crucible, and the design implications of working without the counterpoise offered by diverse stakeholders.
Section III. Rethinking “Inform” is a discussion of types of outreach approaches: podium (talking at) and adult learning learning (talking with and supporting citizen-selection of focus areas). The Web is (and will increasingly be) suited to adult learning. When should agencies use an adult learning mode, and how deep does the culture shift have to be for them to accomplish it?
Secion IV. BLM and Us describes the not-quite-consultant, not-quite-neutral relationship our team had with BLM, the importance of agency buy-in, and the consequences of lack of role clarity.
Section V. Traditional Facilitation relates our experiences within this project using traditional face-to-face techniques in conjunction with web design.
Section VII. Cypepioneering, the longest section, describes our innovative interactive web approaches, such as online map commenting and multi-criteria decision support.
Section VIII. Comment Analysis draws attention to the importance of the comment –analysis-report cycle in public participation. As a system, it tends to teach people and agencies how to communicate less effectively.
The report is written by Carie Fox, formerly a mediator CEO of Fox Mediation, with Philip Murphy, a decision scientist and CEO of InfoHarvest.
Here is the complete PDF report.
For over fifty years, psychologists have been researching how people form conclusions about their own thought processes and those of others. Attribution theories have shed light on cognitive errors that...By Daryl Landau
From the Disputing Blog of Karl Bayer, Victoria VanBuren, and Holly Hayes.[Ed. note: see our previous posts about this case here and here.] The U.S. Court of Appeals for the...By Victoria VanBuren
The New Jersey Supreme Court’s Advisory Committee on Professional Ethics and the Committee on the Unauthorized Practice of Law recently considered the question of whether a lawyer, who provides lobbying...By Robert Lenrow