Find Mediators Near You:

Common Sense Trumps Law In Mediation Every Time

The plaintiff side ran a very, very narrow and technical legal argument.

They argued that a court would never – read my lips – ever – find that the plaintiff contributed to its own loss as a result of a fraud, notwithstanding the fraud by the defendant’s employee went undetected, in large part, because of the plaintiff’s woeful back office systems.

And they had contributory negligence cases to die for – even a House of Lords decision bang on point – which go down big here… apparently the Law Lords say you can’t steal from an innocent then, when you’re caught, blame the victim saying that they made it too easy for you to do so.

Hmmm… actually that might have a logic to it.

But the plaintiff’s CEO got it – he knew blind freddy could have driven a truck through his systems. He couldn’t go into an open courtroom and argue that his publicly traded company had no responsibility based on a House of Lords case no one in his world would take the time to understand.

Once he understood the architecture of the argument he didn’t care what the case said or what the five lawyers in the room said the case said – the laws of his marketplace were far more powerful, and he knew it.

                        author

Geoff Sharp

Geoff Sharp is a Commercial Mediator from Wellington, New Zealand. Geoff works in the Asia Pacific region, including New Zealand, Malaysia, Thailand and Pacific Islands. He is a mediator resolving business problems. He is a fellow of the International Academy of Mediators and mediates complex and hotly debated litigation covering… MORE >

Featured Members

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

McIssac, Hugh: Family Culture Requires Change in Response – Video

Hugh McIssac examines the family in a historical context and what changes have come about recently that require more diverse responses.

By Hugh McIssac
Category

What Challenging Workplace Behavior Are You Dealing with in the New Year?

Texas Conflict Coach Audio Blog by Pattie Porter For the past year, Conflict Connections and MH Mediate have been developing a set of resources to help people address the ten...

By Patricia Porter
Category

Restrain The Pitbulls And Release The Attentive Questioners For Theirs Is The Kingdom Of Resolution

Don't Let the Mediator Bully the Parties from Six Ways to Insure Your Construction Mediation Will Fail over at the Construction Law Musings Blog. A mediator who is bullying you...

By Victoria Pynchon
×