Search Mediators Near You:

Guido V. Duane Morris: Court Requires Kabuki Dance For Mediated Settlement

From Rich Webb’s Healthcare Neutral ADR Blog.

     Earlier this year I wrote about the oral argument before the New Jersey Supreme Court in Guido v. Duane Morris. The case concerns the plaintiffs’ right to sue their former lawyers for malpractice based upon a settlement the plaintiffs accepted after mediation two years earlier. It required the Court to reconcile two previous opinions, Puder v. Buechel, 183 N.J. 428 (2005) and Ziegelheim v. Appollo, 128 N.J. 250 (1992). In a decision handed down last week, the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled that the former clients could overcome a motion for summary judgment and proceed to trial – essentially to attempt to prove that the settlement agreed to by them could have been better but for the negligence of their former lawyers.

     Despite assurances in the Court’s opinion to the contrary, Guido paints a large bullseye on every lawyer whose client has second thoughts about a mediated settlement after the ink is dry. Significantly, the Court emphasized that when putting the mediated settlement in Guido on the record,

"unlike in Puder, plaintiffs did not represent to the court that
they were satisfied with the settlement, or that the settlement
was fair and adequate.
(emphasis added) The entirety of the colloquy between the court and plaintiffs concerning the settlement addressed but two questions:  whether plaintiffs understood and agreed to abide by the settlement terms, and whether plaintiffs were subject to any impediments in understanding those terms.  Glaringly absent is any representation by plaintiffs that the settlement was ‘fair’ and ‘adequate,’ a representation deemed crucial in Puder."


      Did the Court really believe that the plaintiffs in Guido v. Duane Morris would not have answered "yes" if asked whether they were satisfied with their settlement, and whether it was fair and adequate? Apparently these are now magic words that all counsel would be wise to include in written acknowledgments from their clients upon approving any mediated settlement.

     [Image: Kitano Odori kabuki dance, by Onihide, April 18, 2009]


Richard J. Webb

In addition to providing alternative dispute resolution services, Richard J .Webb practices law as Richard J. Webb, LLC. He has been engaged in the private practice of law in New Jersey since 1978, focusing on the healthcare industry for the last 27 years. Before starting his own firm he was… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Your Memory is like the Telephone Game: Each time you recall an event, Your Brain Distorts It

Neuroscience and Conflict Resolution Blog by Stephanie West AllenRelated to my last post which was on the malleability of memory . . . News release from Northwestern University: Remember the telephone game where...

By Stephanie West Allen

A New Year’s Resolution: To Balance Fairness and Victimhood through Mediation

Arthur Brooks wrote an interesting article in Sunday’s New York Times titled, “The Real Victims of Victimhood”. There, he reluctantly acknowledged that America has grown into a country with...

By Jan Frankel Schau

A Mediator’s Fantasy: The Perfect Mediation

Originally published in the Oregon State Bar Bulletin (November 2009). Republished with permission.Unable to sleep one night after a particularly arduous, frustrating, and contentious mediation (though the case settled), I...

By Richard Spier

Find a Mediator