Find Mediators Near You:

Neutral Analysis: A Powerful and Effective Tool

JAMS ADR Blog by Chris Poole

In a wide range of disputes, counsel and their clients have increasingly turned to neutral analysis and evaluation. When conducted by experienced neutral professionals with no preconceived view of the issues, neutral analysis is a powerful and effective tool in helping parties better understand, and even settle their dispute. Often called a second set of eyes or a clear-eyed assessment, neutral analysis is much more than a case evaluation with a predicted outcome or settlement suggestion.

Traditional case evaluation, which is required by many courts, provides the parties with an evaluation outcome and potential sanctions for rejection. While some case insights are provided in the natural course of this approach, modern neutral analysis is much broader. And, there are many creative ways neutral analysis can be designed and conducted ranging from a narrower specific approach to a much wider use.
Where the neutral is a former judge, neutral analysis offers a view from the other side of the bench with deep, detailed insights on the case issues, presentation and likely outcomes. A former judge or justice brings these unique years of experiences to neutral analysis. A non-judicial neutral with extensive trial experience or substantive subject-matter expertise can bring other experience to the analysis as well as a view from counsel’s perspective having represented clients in disputes. Let us examine this in a bit more detail.


Featured Members

View all

Read these next


First Component of an Integrated Conflict Management System: Dispute Resolution Models

In a previous editorial I provided a checklist to enable you to assess the gaps between your organization’s conflict management practices and respected best practices. I described the two components...

By Jennifer Lynch

The Illusion Of Communication

Take a moment to read this quote, “The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place.” – George Bernard Shaw This is a problem that...

By Jason Dykstra

Make Money Mediating Podcast 502: The Secret Sauce to a Great Practice: Client Feedback for the Win

The Crucial Role of Client Feedback in Mediation In this episode of the 'Make Money Mediating' podcast, host Susan Guthrie discusses the importance of client feedback in effectively managing a...

By Susan Guthrie