Find Mediators Near You:

The Merits of Early Neutral Evaluation

JAMS ADR Blog by Chris Poole

I am a professional mediator – and a passionate devotee of its virtues. Mediation, however, can take many forms, depending on the individual needs of a particular dispute or its parties. In my book, for example, I address the uses and benefits of Early Neutral Evaluation and outline when ENE might be a better alternative for a particular dispute.

ENE aims to position the case for early resolution by settlement, dispositive motion or trial. It may serve as a cost-effective substitute for formal discovery and pretrial motions. Although settlement is not the major goal of ENE, the process can lead to settlement.

In ENE, the parties and their lawyers can be confident that they have seen every bit of evidence and heard all the arguments that has gone into the evaluator’s mind before they form their assessment of the merits. There is no ex parte communication with the neutral before they commit their evaluation to writing. In ENE, the parties also know that the same assessment is being presented to each of them – because they hear it at the same time. And they can be confident that the evaluative inputs they hear are rooted in the evidence and law. 

Typically ENE can enhance communication between the parties about their claims and supporting evidence, provide an assessment of the merits of the case by a neutral, provide a “reality check” for clients and lawyers and identify and clarify the central issues in dispute.

Ultimately, there are significant differences between ENE and mediation, as well as between various forms of mediation – and wise counsel will attend carefully to those differences when helping their clients select the form of ADR that promises to best meet the needs that will play the most important roles in positioning their case for disposition – by agreement or otherwise. 

                        author

Wayne Brazil

Hon. Wayne D. Brazil (Ret.) is fully engaged as a neutral at JAMS, after earning a national and international reputation as one of the most significant innovators and leaders in the field of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). He is an expert in crafting procedures to meet the needs of individual… MORE >

Featured Members

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Mediators Pull Plug On Efforts To Enact Uniform Mediation Act In Massachusetts

In 1985, the Massachusetts legislature enacted a statute creating a privilege for mediation communications. As it turned out, despite the good intentions of its makers, it proved to be a...

By Diane J. Levin
Category

Life-Long Learning for Mediators

CMP Resolution Blog by Lesley Allport and Katherine Graham.When I train mediators I explain there are four main ingredients to their learning: the structure of mediation the language and approach...

By Patrick Moulsdale
Category

ACR Taskforce on Safety: Recommended Guidelines — Final Part 3 in Series

Read Part 2 here C. What to Do in Case of Actual or Threatened Violence ADR practitioners continuously assess the behavior of parties and their ability to participate safely in...

By Stephen Kotev
×