There is no principle I hold more dear than the rule of law. I’ve written before about some critics’ contention that our own government has turned away from the rule of law here. Some of those critics go so far as to accuse our government of waging war on the rule of law — calling its strategy “lawfare.”
I’ve also written before about critcisms levelled against ADR practices as threats to the principle that all men, women, and institutions will be judged by the same gender-blind, color-blind, nationality-blind, disability-blind (etc.) rules of law.
There are those who believe that mediation — which is practiced without rules, best practices or even a common theoretical basis — permits mediators — who are primarily over-40 white men — to unfairly pressure litigants to settle their lawsuits against their better judgment. There are further charges that mediation re-injects favortism and prejudice back into a system that spent most of the latter half of the 20th century ridding itself of.
I take these criticisms very very seriously, repeating throughout any mediation session my opening assertion that my role is to present the parties with choices and to faciliate a settlement if they believe it may be better alternative to continued litigation, not to hustle them away from their right to a jury trial.
I would be far more successful in being “neutral” about proceeding to a jury trial if there were an easier, less costly, and speedier way to bring a dispute before a jury. We have, lamentably, permitted our cherished rule of law to become so procedurally encrusted that it sometimes seems like no option at all — at least not an option available to all but the wealthy or those represented by lawyers willing to accept a contingent fee.
All of this troubles me. I invite comment at the same time that I provide the thoughts of some of our greatest statesmen and jurists about the right to trial by jury.
“There was not a member of the Constitutional Convention who had the least objection to what is contended for by the advocates for a Bill of Rights and trial by jury.” (1788)
“Representative government and trial by jury are the heart and lungs of liberty. Without them we have no other fortification against being ridden like horses, fleeced like sheep, worked like cattle and fed and clothed like swine and hounds.” (1774)
“I consider trial by jury as the only anchor ever yet imagined by man, by which a government can be held to the principles of its constitution.” (1788)
“Trial by jury is part of that bright constellation which has gone before us and guided our steps through an age of revolution and reformation.” (1801)
“The wisdom of our sages and the blood of our heroes has been devoted to the attainment of trial by jury. It should be the creed of our political faith.” (1801)
“Trial by jury in civil cases is as essential to secure the liberty of the people as any one of the pre-existent rights of nature.” (1789)
John Quincy Adams
“The struggle for American independence was for chartered rights, for English liberties, for trial by jury, habeas corpus and Magna Carta.” (1839)
Patrick Henry of Virginia [Patriot who said “Give me liberty or give me death!”]
“Trial by jury is the best appendage of freedom by which our ancestors have secured their lives and property. I hope we shall never be induced to part with that excellent mode of trial.” (1788)
“The friends and adversaries of the plan of the convention, if they agree in nothing else, concur at least in the value they set upon the trial by jury; the former regard it as a valuable safeguard to liberty; the latter represent it as the very palladium of free government.” (1788)
“The protection of life and property, habeas corpus, trial by jury, the right of an open trial, these are principles of public liberty existing in the best form in the republican institutions of this country.” (1848)
Judge Stephen Reinhardt
“Our constitutional right to trial by jury does not turn on the political mood of the moment, the outcome of cost/benefit analyses or the results of economic or fiscal calculations. There is no price tag on the continued existence of the civil jury system, or any other constitutionally-provided right.” (1986)
“Trial by jury is the best institution calculated for the preservation of liberty and the administration of justice that was ever devised by the wit of man.” (1762)
Judge William Bryant [First African-American federal district court judge in D.C]
“If it weren’t for lawyers, I’d still be three-fifths of a man.” (2004)
Justice William O. Douglas
“The Massachusetts Body of Liberties was a new Magna Carta. It contained many of the seeds of the civil liberties which today distinguish us from the totalitarian systems, including the right to trial by jury.” (1954)
Justice Hugo Black
“Our duty to preserve the Seventh Amendment is a matter of high Constitutional importance. The founders of our country thought that trial by civil jury was an essential bulwark of civil liberty and it must be scrupulously safeguarded.” (1939, 1943)
Justice Ward Hunt
“Twelve jurors know more of the common affairs of life than does one man, and they can draw wiser and safer conclusions than a single judge.” (1873)
Quotations excerpted from In Defense of Trial by Jury: Vols. I and II by the American Jury Trial Foundation (1993) and copied verbatim and in their entirety from the web site of the American Association of Justice (i.e., the American Trial Lawyers Association).
Este artículo fue escrito inicialmente en inglés. La traducción es de Alberto Piedra. La versión original fue editada por Merri l. Hanson, Directora de Peninsula Mediation & ADR (www.peninsulamediation.com Diaz...By Luis Miguel Diaz
Jeff Kichaven writes on mediation for the International Risk Management Institute. First published on IMRI.com. It's a common practice. And, it's generally a mistake. Participants are more likely to achieve...By Jeff Kichaven
From the RSI BlogI am in my third month now serving as Director of Foreclosure Mediation for RSI. When I visit our foreclosure mediation programs in Rockford, Geneva and Waukegan...By Hannah Kaufman