To Resolve A Dispute, Ask Your Adversary For Advice

From the Blog of Phyllis G. Pollack.

 In the June 2007 issue of Negotiation, Katie A. Liljenquist and Adam D. Galinsky discuss how to “Turn Your Adversary Into Your Advocate.” Their advice is simple: Ask for advice. A request for advice will always be much more effective than an adversial approach.

 The authors note that there are multiple benefits to seeking advice. First, “soliciting advice helps you find solutions to genuine problems.” (Id. at 2). It also can “disarm potentially defensive opponents.” As the authors aptly point out, “when you ask someone for advice rather than issuing demands or attacks, you frame your negotiation as a joint problem-solving task, and establish a norm of collaboration.” (Id.)

 The second benefit is flattery: “Asking a fellow negotiator for advice is an implicit endorsement of her opinions, values and expertise.” (Id.) It also shows respect.

 The third benefit is that it causes the other person (aka your adversary) to look at the situation from your perspective. Upon doing so, the other party will better understand your “underlying interests, find creative solutions and avoid harsh attributions for [your] behavior.”

 A fourth benefit is commitment: “Delivering advice requires a small amount of time but it engenders a sense of commitment that can be invaluable. . . . [A] negotiator who is asked for and gives advice is much more likely to follow through on any agreement she helps to create.” (Id. at 3). In giving advice upon request, the other person takes on a degree of responsibility for the outcome and thus feels a sense of commitment.

 In concluding their article, the authors provide three guidelines on how to ask for advice: (1) express your overall competence first; (2) make your request specific; and (3) emphasize the exclusivity of your request. (Id. at 3).
 As the authors explain, many people do not like to ask for advice for fear of appearing weak. To overcome this, start your request by affirming your general competence and then seek the advice on a discrete topic. In doing so, be very specific. A generalized request for advice will often be met with a vague and unhelpful response. But, asking for help on a detailed point will provoke the response you seek. Finally, make a point of telling the other person why you are asking them and not someone else: why they are uniquely qualified to help you. (Id.)

 Consequently, the next time you are in a dispute with someone, ask them for their advice on how to resolve it. By doing so, the other person will work with you, rather than against you, and in all probability, the dispute will be resolved.
 . . . Just something to think about. 


Phyllis Pollack

Phyllis Pollack with PGP Mediation uses a facilitative, interest-based approach. Her preferred mediation style is facilitative in the belief that the best and most durable resolutions are those achieved by the parties themselves. The parties generally know the business issues and priorities, personalities and obstacles to a successful resolution as… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


Kamikaze Conflict – How Might It Damage Your Franchise System?

First published by Franchise New Zealand This article considers the potential for franchising systems to be undermined by kamikaze conflict, involving people acting in ways that appear to be against...

By Jeff Giddings, Lorelle Frazer

Private Means for Public Justice? Professor Murray Responds

After generously commenting on my own comments to his article on the Privitization of Justice (any chance I can get permission to publish it here Professor?), Harvard Law School Professor Peter Murray...

By Victoria Pynchon

How to Bring Civility to Political Arguments

Civility, respect, understanding, and the willingness to listen. These are core conversational virtues that are universally appreciated. What’s interesting is that, although we all want to see these admirable virtues...

By Kwame Christian

Find a Mediator