Did you ever play “truth or dare” as a kid? I did, and I remember those anxious moments leading up to my choice of truth, or dare. Of course, I knew if I chose TRUTH I might “have” to divulge something about myself I would prefer to keep private. But, if I chose DARE I might “have” to do something I really did not want to do. Either choice could take me somewhere I didn’t want to go, or it could be no big deal at all – even fun!
Having experienced the three primary roles of mediation (plaintiff, defendant, and mediator), I recognize that participating in mediation can be a bit like playing Truth or Dare. During the game, players make a choice regarding what action they are going to take, then put themselves in the hands of the other players and hope they are not superficially damaged in some way. During mediation, the participating parties make decisions regarding how much “truth” they will divulge (to the mediator and/or the other party) and how far they “dare” to move in their negotiations. They then place a level of confidence in the mediator, and hope their case will not be damaged in any way as she communicates with the
other side about their positions.
There is an interesting dichotomy that occurs during mediation: generally the adverse parties have an earnest interest in resolving their case, which requires a fairly high degree of openness. However, the parties also experience varying levels of angst when deciding what information to release, and taking the calculated risk of increasing their offer or reducing their demand. I have observed there is invariably a turning point, when the energy in the room is palpable and decisions are being made. Decisions which will determine the mediation outcome; impasse or press on to agreement. It is at this time the parties choose whether or not to have faith in me, as their mediator, to keep confidences and maintain a balanced process. They also decide whether or not to trust me to articulate their truths, even as they dare to move in their negotiations. Certainly, these choices may be viewed as risks. Interestingly however, it is typically this very decision (this sometimes painful decision) that generates the momentum required to create a real opportunity for resolution. It is at this point, as I observe the parties making their decisions, that the Jeopardy theme song (different game, I know) starts playing in my head, and remains until the mediation concludes. This is the fork in the road; resolution or continued litigation hangs in these choices.
As the party involved in the case, these are your decisions to make. As your mediator, it is my role to accept your decisions without judgment, honor confidentiality, and work to ensure the mediation process does no harm. It is also my desire to produce a positive experience for you.
As you decide, I recommend you recall the rules of mediation:
In my experience, the more open the parties are with me (regarding their interests and positions in the case), the more likely I am to be successful in facilitating resolution – even when the information I have been given is confidential and never divulged to the adverse party.
What will you choose during your next mediation: Truth or Dare? Both or neither? Like during the childhood game, there may be anxious moments of decision during mediation, but that’s where the similarities end. You will never “have” to divulge anything you would prefer to keep private, and you will never “have” to do anything you really do not want to do. Have a little faith in the process, and I bet you will be satisfied with the result.
Disputing Blog by Karl Bayer, Victoria VanBuren, and Holly HayesHamline University School of Law Professor Sharon Press has published Mediator Ethical Breaches: Implications for Public Policy, Penn State Yearbook on...By Beth Graham
Often when I speak about conflict and dispute resolution I mention three words that I consider to be my mantra in regards to Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Communication, Understanding and...By Jeff Thompson
Recently I had the privilege of attending a meeting where the presenter gave a powerful talk about how to engage with people. His story is in itself amazing, especially his...By Denise Evans