Find Mediators Near You:

Giving Yourself Permission

PGP Mediation Blog by Phyllis G. Pollack

The holidays are upon us, and with them come the usual stress and tension that family events often bring. Over Thanksgiving, I had an experience that put it in perspective for me. Although I am supposed to be the conflict resolution person, it was a cousin that gave me a very much needed "reality check", if not "permission" to think differently about family loyalty.

The issue arose nearly two years ago when I made a statement to a relative (I will call her "Jane".) that upset her. Realizing immediately what I had done, I sent her a card apologizing. Evidently, the apology was not sufficient because her response to another family member was negative. Only begrudgingly did she agree that I could be invited to an upcoming family event.

Hearing this from the family member, I decided not to attend. For the next two years, I neither saw nor spoke to Jane. (It was Jane who did not want to speak to me.)

Earlier this year, a relative from out of state proposed coming to our house for Thanksgiving and having the family over like the old days. The relative had not been here for Thanksgiving for over a decade.

For me, this proposition brought on a huge dilemma. What to do about Jane? My own instincts and my upbringing told me that family was family, and I should be loyal and forgive and forget no matter what. But, at the same time, during the last couple of years, some things had happened in my life that Jane did not even acknowledge which upset me greatly (together with the non acceptance of my apology.) The result was that I did not really want Jane to attend Thanksgiving in my house. So- what do I do?

But then, a couple of nights before Thanksgiving, several of us went out to dinner including a cousin. (I am not the only one having issues with Joe.) My cousin started discussing Jane’s behavior with me and gave me the "reality check" I needed. She understood the situation completely, and while it is idyllic that everyone gets along, in reality it does not always happen that way, and that is okay! Sometimes, family members behave quite badly to the point of "crossing the line" and if that occurs, it is okay not to include them in family events. In fact, the rest of the family may be better off as the tension and stress of having that family member there, will be absent. So… as much as I was raised on the idyllic family values of "Leave it to Beaver", "The Donna Reed Show" and "The Nelsons", my cousin explained that this is not "real life" and it is okay for families not to behave that way. She, in effect, gave me permission to stop hitting my head against the wall expecting a different result.

So, we had Thanksgiving dinner without Jane, and the consensus was that it was very pleasant and stress free. A very enjoyable time was had by all!

So… as much as it goes against my upbringing and family values to exclude family at holidays, I now see that it is okay to do so, if the situation warrants it. Not every family lives in Never Never Land nor will there always be a ‘happy" ending. Maybe, sometimes the "happy" ending IS the exclusion of a family member !

I post this confession as I believe it is fitting for the coming days. While we all want to get along with family and think that it is the "proper" thing to do, at the same time, we may just have to give ourselves permission or a "reality check" that is okay if everyone does NOT get along and to accept that fact and act accordingly.

…. I am going to take my annual holiday vacation from blogging and so will be back in early January 2015. Have a wonderful holiday and a great 2015!

And most of all, thank you for reading my many blogs this past year!

… Just something to think about.


Phyllis Pollack

Phyllis Pollack with PGP Mediation uses a facilitative, interest-based approach. Her preferred mediation style is facilitative in the belief that the best and most durable resolutions are those achieved by the parties themselves. The parties generally know the business issues and priorities, personalities and obstacles to a successful resolution as… MORE >

Featured Mediators

View all

Read these next


BATNAs: A Practical Tool for Mediators and a Risk

In his article “Do You Use ‘BATNA’ Wrong” (Mediate, January 3, 2018) and in a subsequent blog titled “Confusing Dispute Resolution Jargon” (featured at Mediate, January 9, 2018), John Lande...

By George Siedel

When You Inadvertently Magnify a Conflict

Conflict doesn’t necessarily mean something fundamental has shifted in your business or personal relationship. It’s possible the relationship is as sound and strong as it ever was. It’s just hard...

By Tammy Lenski

Albie Davis: Feeling Honored When Parties Were Entrusting – Video

Albie Davis describes an early experience where she felt honored to have people entrust her with the intimate detail of their lives, from which she had a strong sense of...

By Albie Davis