The Problem With Court Mediation

It’s early in the week for another article of substance and I usually try to back end them, but this one is an exception.

A new article in the George Mason Law Review by Leonard Riskin and Nancy Welsh just might scratch an itch for many of us.

Is that All There is? ‘The Problem’ in Court-Oriented Mediation says that court-oriented mediation now reflects the dominance of lawyers and insurance claims adjusters – and one shot players are not catered for.

Riskin/Welsh opine that these repeat players understand the problem to be addressed in personal injury, employment, contract, medical malpractice and civil non-family disputes as a matter of merits assessment and litigation risk analysis – but say court mediation programs fail to meet expectations and needs of ordinary one time users – mediation is structured so that litigation issues predominate; other issues – personal, psychological, relational, communitarian – disappear.

Abstract: The “alternative” process of mediation is now well-institutionalized and widely (though not universally) perceived to save time and money and satisfy lawyers and parties.
However, the process has failed to meet important aspirations of its early proponents and certain expectations and needs of one-shot players.
In particular, court-oriented mediation now reflects the dominance and preferences of lawyers and insurance claims adjusters. These repeat players understand “the problem” to be addressed in personal injury, employment, contract, medical malpractice and other “ordinary” civil non-family disputes as a matter of merits assessment and litigation risk analysis.
Mediation is structured so that litigation issues predominate; other potential issues – personal, psychological, relational, communitarian – disappear. [read more]

                        author

Geoff Sharp

Geoff Sharp is a Commercial Mediator from Wellington, New Zealand. Geoff works in the Asia Pacific region, including New Zealand, Malaysia, Thailand and Pacific Islands. He is a mediator resolving business problems. He is a fellow of the International Academy of Mediators and mediates complex and hotly debated litigation covering… MORE >

Featured Mediators

ad
View all

Read these next

Category

Virtual Mediation Can and Must Be Done Right

Computer screens buzzing with distraction. Background noise. Fidgeting with camera angles. Bad lighting, echos and muffled voices. Now add strangers in the background, waiting rooms, unreliable internet connections. Mediators, hold...

By Kathleen Young
Category

Mediator’s Proposals? A Story…

Kluwer Mediation BlogI have never been a great fan of mediator’s proposals. I took the view that the mediator’s job, done well, was to help the parties to come to...

By John Sturrock
Category

Have We Lost the Ability to be Curious?

CMP Resolution Blog by Lesley Allport and Katherine Graham. Adrian Chiles in The Guardian recently made the point that “on all media, mainstream and social…nobody wants to know stuff; they...

By Arran Heal

Find a Mediator

X
X
X